I finally had an opportunity to try Picnicky's Sandwich Shop on Sonoma Boulevard this week and they did NOT disappoint! I had the pleasure of tasting The Caveman and The Sausalito and both were quite satisfying. I've been looking for a local sandwich shop to call my favorite and for the time being, this will take on that title. I've heard many good things about the sandwiches at Food Basket so that will definitely be next on my list of places to try soon.
For now, Picnicky's is easily my top choice. They provide an overall great value with fair prices, substantial portions, and great ingredients (the bread is SO soft and tasty!) If I were to make one critique it would be regarding the very limited options for side dishes. It's not a big deal for me because I typically skimp on side orders when I'm at a favorite sandwich shop but I'm sure other's may appreciate a wider variety to choose from.
Just a few steps away from Bud's Burgers, a true Vallejo staple - be sure to give Picnicky's a shot if you're in the area and haven't already done so!